Thursday, July 14, 2011

The deflation-inflation contraption for a fiat currency used as global reserve

I apologize for not having time to write a more detailed entry on this very interesting subject but Utterlycorrelated has a small readership, which I assume is already familiar with many of the strange ideas and opinions expressed here.

I will try to make my ramblings as as a collection of brief points.

First as it has been said quite a few times here on this blog, USD is a curious fiat construct based on self referenced debt since the Nixon Shock. There is absolutely no risk to have a long lasting and major deflationary event in US since the Bernank can summon the helicopters and print till the end of paper stocks. However the Fed has the ability to induce brief deflationary shocks which can have a devastating effect on the rest of the world which holds its reserves in USD, or in a proxy currency pegged directly or indirectly on USD.

These brief deflationary shocks can be very easy to induce due to three other factors:
1) USD is still overvalued since US us used as the largest consumer market and the importer of last resort.
2) US governmental debt and most of US private debt is denominated exclusively in USD (or in a proxy currency) which makes it an equivalent of domestic debt since it represents future liability on the US taxpayers.
3) Taking advantage of the 2008 Crisis the Fed has started the third piece of the scam by offering interest on excess reserves. Few people understand yet the power conferred by this relative obscure tool. By keeping both the interest paid on excess reserves and the discount window close to zero, the Fed has placed itself in a discontinuity monetary point which allows it to play with risk exactly as the Bernanke wants, without creating any inflationary or deflationary effects or by the contrary to generate inflationary or deflationary effects at will without modifying significantly the monetary aggregate. Basically the whole world is now kept hostage to the USD and the Fed and there is nothing they can do.

The game with interest paid on excess reserves is pretty simple: it hides risk. Let's say that Fed's discount window is 0.25% and the interest paid on reserves is also 0.25%. The Fed can lend to JPM $170 billion and JPM parks all this money back to the Fed as excess reserves. Cost for hiding JPM risk is zero for both the Fed and JPM and nonexistent virtual money with zero inflationary or deflationary effect is created out of nothing as a balance sheet artefact.

The interesting part is that the rate of growth of these unnatural and virtual excess reserves is a leading indicator of inflationary-deflationary events since it is dependent on the expectation of loses on bank capital. If we look at a chart of the EXCRENS evolution and at a inflation deflation indicator as the Finster Dollar Index the correlation is pretty clear. One may say that the double dip recession has already started in February-May 2008.

The problem is that this game of smoke an mirrors, makes the current definition of M1 money multiplier a joke. Officially it is well below 1. If we take out the virtual and illusory excess reserves out of the monetary base we obtain a corrected value which gives us a very interesting picture.

As it appears we are right now at the beggining of a new deflationary move, but only Bernanke knows how long he is going to hold it. Of course the first move is the flight to safety into PM, so we can see gold and silver shooting through the sky. The next step is deleveraging and covering position which in a deflationary event means selling the highly liquid PM( with a diving of gold and especially of silver) and we may see a crowding back to ... treasuries and we will see again the T yields flooring and LIBOR sky rocketing. This will burn again big time all the gold and silver bugs.

Currently the US Treasury paper is the international reserve currency not the USD (on which all T paper is referenced to). Let's say that there is a US Gov default and coupon payments are not made due to the bickering in the Clowngress.

In such situation we will have a major transient FX move with USD taking a dive. This will have a devastating effect on both China and EU which will see their currency soaring. If the yuan soars there will be game over for China because the Chinese export machine will collapse at the same time with the collapse of the real estate and development bubble.

EU will do slightly better in a first stage since a very high EUR will alleviate the pains of the PIIGS, which for a short would believe they have won the lottery. In the end it will hit the rich EU North which would be send in a huge trade deficit since their export will collapse (Germany, France and Netherlands will become the importers of last resort). The ECB by definition cannot call the helicopters to inflate.

The only problem is that it will be impossible for the ECB to generate enough debt, fast enough to allow for an orderly retreat of the international currency reserves from USD to EUR... The PIIGS are not big enough and unless the EU big players don't start running big deficits and gov debt, the EUR cannot replace USD.

My whole rambling is about the fact that in the case of a self referenced debt international reserve currency (such as the USD is) the whole notion of default is relative because of the Fx arbitrage, which keeps all creditors hostage to the Dollar (which is the index for T debt). If the show must go on US has to continue to run the so called "unsustainable deficits" in order to satisfy the appetite for reserve currency of the rest of the world otherwise the whole mechanism collapses.

If this appetite seems to vanish, the solution is simple: have the Fed engineer a deflationary shock in order to floor the Tsy yields even if USD in falling in Fx markets. I believe this is the perfect scam.

(I apologize for any spelling mistakes or poor grammar in writing this entry, but I an writing it on my laptop in a cab while rushing to a meeting. I have to stop editing now since I have just reached destination).

10 comments:

Cassander said...

Great piece! Question: if congress pushes the default button, what is to keep the EU clowns from doing the same with the PIIGS, and get the euro to tank as well? Wouldnt that force China to load up the bag even further?

CLN said...

@ Cassander - Structurally the ECB cannot inflate the Euro. In simple terms the Euro is an artificial construct created by linking 17 national fiat currencies through a system similar to the Bretton Woods Agreement.

The tricky part which fools everybody is that all these currencies are pegged to each other to a rigid 1:1 ratio and there is a forced convertibility.

What we see now with the PIIGS is the stress produced on the system by the effort to keep the Greek, Italian, Irish and Spaniard components at the same value with the EUR components of Germany France and other countries with better economies.

Germany and France have now the option of paying for the losses of the PIIGS to maintain the EUR as a whole or to abandon some of the members and loose the size of the construct.

A rapid general devaluation of the EUR for all 17 member states would be impossible without increasing the stress in the system to the breaking point since a lot of PIIGS debt is held internally by EU banks.

A rapid appreciation of the EUR, as a result of a run from USD as reserve currency will heart the heavy weights of the EU. It's a perfect Catch 22. EUR is doomed unless it remains a proxy for USD. There is no exit here.

The EU clowns cannot simply push the default button without shooting themselves in the leg and destroying their European internal wealth transfer tool (EUR). ECB has way more less room for manoeuvre than the Fed. Unless all the 17 members of the EUR space don't relinquish a significant measure of their national sovereignty, by giving total control of their fiscal policies to Berlin (which is not going to happen soon) there is no way ECB can become a real central bank like the FED.

Morgan said...

Well pardon me for not expounding on this scenario. One would have thought it would be a cold day in hell before the US would declare economic war on Core Europe/Japan.

In the short term would this not implode the US consumer credit markets, unless accompanied by massive stimulus?

Yes, this could prop up gov't debt issuance in resource based EM's.

What would be the real goal here?

To force Germany and Japan to massively outsource to the US and EM's?

Or to force Core Europe to allow PE firms to carve up Private German manufacturing to benefit Oligarchs?

CLN said...

@ Morgan. I apologize for being to elliptic in my arguments. The Fed won't declare war on EU and Japan. I've always said these are members of the Coalition of the Zirping and are in fact part of the banking army of Fed minions.

However, a tangent hit to send EU in a brief deflationary shock, would be in effect much applauded by the top EU bureaucrats, because it would create a "good crisis" which would be perfect to exploit in a Problem-Reaction-Solution (Hegelian Dialectic) in order to push for a fiscal integration in the EU and transform EUR into a real currency.

Without authority to tax the euro-proles and other hapless PIIGS, EUR has to be propped to survive.

I was talking about the so called "catastrophic scenarios" in case the debt ceiling is not going to be approved. They would be as "catastrophic" as not doing the first Great Bailout of 2008 for the Vampire Squid and other banking parasites.

Of course the Fed wants to have more debt issued and keep Japan, EU, UK, SK, Canada, Australia and a few other countries afloat with generous swap lines.

What I was trying to say is that in the current construct of USD as circular self referenced debt, sold in an interest bearing form as international reserve currency, the final netting of such a "catastrophic" event will be neted by Fx arbing. That is all.

Unfortunately, unless the Fed plans just a brief deflationary shock to shake PBoC, the debt ceiling will be approved no matter what (after putting on the media the whole scare tactics show for the herd of clueless proles, who are going to end up paying for most of the expenses of this new financial scam.

Morgan said...

@CLN

Oh of course Fx arbing, I'm slapping my head here.

I think its awesome that "self referenced debt as international reserve currency" just springs to your mind when writing in the back of a NYC cab.

I was once mentally debating the rival merits of egg salad vs knish when I accidentally made eye contact with the cabby. He thought I was an EU tourist and gave me the guide to tipping.

Any chance you could tone it down a bit for the innumerate and basis swap challenged?

CLN said...

@ Morgan. Sorry for being so elliptic and opaque in my ramblings but I was in a hurry. I'll do my best to pursue more clarity next time (it's not about toning down).

GTT said...

I see two very interesting developments today.

1) Gold and *especially* mining stocks decouple from equities and trade inversely.

2) AUD decouples from equities.

qadi said...

I appreciate CLN taking the load: thank you!

My only update: Syria is going the way of Libya.

Agree with CLN 100% on debt ceiling. I also agree that Eurobonds ought to be in the future.

Gold/silver have outlived their usefulness, imo.

CLN said...

@ GTT - With respect to gold and equities I believe that for time being this is just the normal jitters of a nervous market. Gold is expected to spike, but the evolution of equities will be determined by the moves made by Fed after the debt ceiling is approved.

With respect to AUD and equities, I simply have no idea what is behind that since I don't follow closely that correlation.

@ qadi . I am trying to do my best to hold the line :)

How sure is this information that Syria is going to go on the Libyan path (with NATO involvement) ?

I believe this is a very interesting piece of information. If the Arab Spring is brought to Damascus and the Alawites are replaced from power by a group from the Sunni majority, that would create a wonderful opportunity for Israel to launch an attack on Iran.

Such an event would be a major game changer.

qadi said...

CLN: when the revolts started in March, I asked a friend, "Why aren't we there?!!" He replied, "You really think we aren't?"

My friend is the sort of guy who works for a boring department in DoD yet takes odd "business trips" and speaks fluent urdu, pashtun, and some arabic.